After hosting Trawick for a workout on, the Ravens signed the safety and special teams player. Trawick, an undrafted free agent and member of the 2013 draft class, signed with the Baltimore Ravens in his rookie year. In his first game as a Raven, Trawick committed a now-infamous play, where he hit return man Jacoby Jones during a punt return, and injured the star player. Trawick remained on the Ravens roster until 2016.
In 2016 Trawick signed with the Oakland Raiders, where he began to build a name for himself as a special team player. After a productive year that included 10 special team tackles, Trawick signed with the Tennessee Titans. Trawick was named to his first Pro Bowl after the 2017 season, which included 17 special team tackles. Trawick played for the Titans throughout 2018 as well.